Labels

Showing posts with label SARFAESI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SARFAESI. Show all posts

Saturday, 8 September 2018

LENDING AGAINST INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ASSETS IN INDIA– THE UNDERLYING CHALLENGES


The 21st Century has seen India transforming itself to a land of young entrepreneurs and startup ventures. Securing funds for a startup is one of the toughest challenges an Entrepreneur faces while starting a new business. In this new dawn of Startups, the Government of India itself has come forward supporting them under various schemes like Startup India and Stand Up India. Banks have donned the new role of handholding these startup ventures by offering them a wide range of credit facilities including term loans or working capital or asset backed loans based on their requirements. Banks like SIDBI are offering special schemes for the startups which can be used for marketing, brand building, creation of distribution network, technical know-how, R&D and software purchase. 
The Government has brought in amendments to the Intellectual Property legal framework in India providing for a liberal fee structure for registering Patents under the Scheme for Facilitating Start-ups IntellectualProperty Protection (SIPP) thereby encouraging the startups to secure protection of the intellectual property created by them under their R&D. In a knowledge-based economy, physical assets such as property, plant and equipment dwindle in importance relative to Intellectual Property assets, which provide access to the latest and most innovative forms of technology and act as barriers to entry by competitors. The Banks can explore to secure their credit facilities by creating enforceable security interest over this intellectual property. However recent decision of the Supreme Court in Canara Bank v N G Subbaraya Setty has created apprehensions amongst the Banks as to the enforceability of security interest created over the intangible property of the borrowers.

Intellectual Property (IP) rights comprise of the underlying intangible rights such as patents, copyrights or trademarks, through which a set of exclusive rights is given to the right holder/s under which they may use the work in an unrestricted manner while others can do so only upon the permission of the right holder/s.[1] A business enterprise may have both identifiable and unidentifiable intangible assets.[2] For instance the Patents, Trademarks, Copyright, designs etc can be generally considered as identifiable intangible assets which enjoy protection as the Intellectual Property of the enterprise. The good will of the business enterprise may also contribute towards the value creation for the company but the same does not count as a protected intellectual property and may not be often quantified or identifiable.

While offering an IP right owned by a business enterprise as a collateral security, a security interest is created in favour of the Creditor over the receivables including future receivables generated from the intellectual property asset/s. Such receivables may include future royalty payments that are likely to be received through the licensing of a patent or a trademark, various rights in the music industry, such as recording rights, the future income from copyrights, distribution rights, etc.[3]

Whether An Enforceable Security Under Indian Legal Framework?

 The Banking Regulation Act, 1956, allows the Banks in India to acquire, hold and generally deal with any property or any right, title or interest in any such property forming the security or part of the security for any loans or advances. Banks can manage, sell or realise any such property that has come into its possession as a security in full or part satisfaction of any of its claims.[4] By virtue of this provision there is no bar on the Banks for accepting an intangible asset of a borrower like patent rights or trademarks for securing the credit facilities offered to the borrower. A security interest so created over an IP right can be enforced by the Banks under provisions of the SARFAESI Act or under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).

By virtue of the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, a secured creditor can enforce any security interest created by the borrower in its favour, by way of a mortgage or an assignment. The Act has defined security interest to include any right, title and interest of any kind upon ‘property’ and the term property has been defined to include know-how, patent, copyright, trade mark, licence, franchise or any other business or commercial right of similar nature.

Similarly the intangible assets of a person, including any company has also been brought under the ambit of the IBC. The scope of IBC covers every description of property situated in India or outside and every description of interest including present or future or vested or contingent interest arising out of, or incidental to, property. IBC also provides for a similar but wider definition for security interest. As per the Code, security interest means right, title or interest or a claim to property, created in favour of, or provided for a secured creditor by a transaction which secures payment or performance of an obligation and includes mortgage, charge, hypothecation, assignment and encumbrance or any other agreement or arrangement securing payment or performance of any obligation of any person[5].

IBC provides for the Resolution professional to take control of the intangible assets including intellectual property of the Corporate Debtor (CD) during the Resolution process.[6] It has been further provided that the intellectual property of the CD shall also form part of the liquidation estate if the CD goes into liquidation[7].

 Legal Framework in India For Creation of Security Interest on IP
I.          Patents
For securing the credit facilities offered by a lender, the proprietor of a patent can create a valid mortgage of his right or assign the patent in favour of the Lender as per the provisions of the Indian Patent Act. In a mortgage of patents, the patent rights are wholly or partly transferred to assignee in return for a sum of money. Under such an assignment the creditor may require the proprietor of the Patent to assign the whole or part of the royalties and other receivables, including future receivables to the creditor by cross licensing or by other means. The lending banks may examine accepting of licensing agreements or royalty streams as either standalone collateral or as part of an asset package to secure a loan.

As per the provisions of the Indian Patents Act, an assignment of a patent or of a share in a patent, a mortgage, licence or the creation of any other interest in a patent shall not be valid unless the same were in writing and the agreement between the parties concerned is reduced to the form of a document embodying all the terms and conditions governing their rights and obligations and duly executed.

Whenever any mortgage or license in a patent is being created, either the mortgagee/licensee or the mortgagor/licensor has to apply in writing in the manner prescribed under the Patent Act for the registration of his title or, as the case may be of notice of his interest in the Register of Patents. Once the mortgagor/assignor repays the sum to the mortgagee/assignee, the patent rights are restored to patentee. The person in whose favour a mortgage is made is not entitled to have his name entered in the register as the proprietor, however he can get his name entered in the register of Patents as the mortgagee. The rights of a mortgagor and a mortgagee of a patent are no different from that of the mortgagor and mortgagee with respect to an immovable property[8].
II.            Trademarks
Reading the ratio in Subbaraya Setty in toto, it can be said that the Court has not barred the acceptance of trademark as a security. As it was rightly pointed out in the Judgement, unless the assignment of trademark has been made part of the loan documentation and has been registered with the Registrar of trademarks, such document/instrument evidencing the assignment will not be admissible in evidence by any Court in proof of title to the trade mark by assignment.[9] While creating the assignment as a security it must be explored and suitably defined under the instrument as to what are the receivables related to the Trademark which may be used for timely service of the credit facility availed and what shall be the right of the Lender in case of any default.
III.            Copyright
No assignment of the copyright in any work shall be valid unless it is in writing and signed by the assignor or by his duly authorised agent. The assignment of copyright should identify such work, and must specify the rights assigned and the duration of such assignment. If the period of assignment is not stated, it shall be deemed to be five years from the date of assignment. Under Section 18 of the Copyright Act, even the copyright in a future work can be assigned in accordance with Section 19, however, such assignment shall come into effect only upon date of creation of the work. It has now been added by the Amendment that no assignment shall be applied to any medium or mode of exploitation of the work, which did not exist or was not in commercial use at the time when the assignment was made, unless the assignment specifically referred to such medium or mode of exploitation of the work. For instance if any financial institution proposes to provide credit facility for production of a cinematograph film, the copy right over the future work and the receivables can be assigned as a security if the same has been specifically mentioned therein under the Deed of assignment.
Further if the borrower is a Company, it shall be required under the Companies Act, 2013 to duly create and register the said charge over its IP assets under the ROC records.
Underlying Challenges For Lenders
a)    Due Diligence and Valuation: Performing due diligence and appraising the IP assets have all along considered to be time consuming and difficult. The first step in due diligence is to ascertain the ownership and gauge the likelihood of future ownership challenges. For instance, in the case of Information Technology sector, the only protection available for the source code is under copyright law. The absence of the requirement of registration of copyrights in India makes it extremely difficult to ascertain prior instances of the work in question, which might potentially be lawsuits for copyright infringement.   
The major drawback associated with trademarks is that that they are closely associated with the goodwill enjoyed by the organization that continues to hold those intangible assets. A decline in the value of the brand would also have a corresponding negative impact on the value of the trademarks associated with that brand. A classic example in this regard is the case of Kingfisher Airlines. The proportionate security cushion that was available to the lenders based on the value of the Brand was substantially eroded to the extent that the value of the brand, being an operating asset, has declined in the market[10].
The rapid technological advancements quite often render several patents obsolete and thereby the licenses that flow from them redundant. Drawing an example from the entertainment industry, the use of cassettes/diskettes as a conventional medium of distribution was totally made obsolete with the advent of digital distribution. Such risks are more in the case of software and semiconductor industries as new versions are being released within a very short span of time, drastically reducing the shelf time of the patents in this field. Such risks will have to be foreseen by the Lenders and should be accounted for at the time of valuation. At the time of valuation the future marketability and commercial potential of the IP assets also have to be considered, by assessing their values as a going-concern and also under liquidation scenario. The IP assets are generally considered as passive assets, where the owner of the IP uses its exclusionary rights to prevent unauthorised competition[11]. While valuing IP assets as collateral, it is important and always advisable to engage an independent third-party expert to ensure the fairness of the valuation and in assessing the future returns. [12]
In the international banking scenario, the Banks have begun to move away from a purely balance-sheet analysis into looking at the cash flow generating capability of the business and to ascertain whether there is adequate, stable cash flow from the business owning the IP asset to service and repay the loan within the stipulated time period[13].
b)      Ensuring Continuing validity: If accepted as collateral, the lender will be creating a “security interest” over the IP asset, which can be seized and sold in the event of a default. During the tenure of the loan the lender will have to ensure that the Borrower has timely renewed the ownership and that he has taken necessary precautions to ensure the continuation of valid IP ownership. As per the legal framework in India the duration of validity of a Patent is Twenty Years and that of the Trademark is Ten years from the date of application. In the case of any default resulting in the Lender/s may end up managing and monitoring potential infringements, defending them from charges of infringement and administering royalty payments. This includes payment of the renewal fees periodically till the liabilities are liquidated.





[1] See Dov Solomon & Miriam Bitton, “Intellectual Property Securitisation”
[2] See Pavri, Zareer  Price Waterhouse  Cooper, “Valuation of Intellectual PropertyAssets”
[3] See Barooah, Swaraj Paul  “Securitisation of IP” 
[4] See Section 6(1) f & g of the Banking Regulation Act, 1956
[5] See Sections 3 (27) & (31) of IBC, 2016
[6] See Section 18(f)(iv) of IBC, 2016
[7] See Section 36 (3) (d) of IBC 2016
[8] See Van Gelder, Apsimon and Co Ltd v The Sowerby Bridge Flour Society Ltd, (1890) 44 Ch 374
[9] See Section 45(2) of the Trademarks Act.
[10] See supra note 3
[11] See Jacqueline Lipton, “ Intellectual Property in the Information Age and Secured Finance Practice” EIPR, 2002, 358, 364
[13] Supra Note 2


Monday, 11 December 2017

THE MORATORIUM UNDER BANKRUPTCY CODE NOT A BAR ON SARFAESI ACTION AGAINST GUARANTOR’S PROPERTIES

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) has been introduced to yield faster results in the recovery of Corporate NPAs. The erstwhile SICA, was enacted to address the corporate debts and to facilitate faster recovery, rehabilitation and revival of the sick company. Contrary to this legislative intention to revive the sick companies, the provisions of SICA were used by the Corporate Debtors to weave a protective cocoon around themselves under BIFR. Thus once a company entered into BIFR, nobody could recover money from them. The need for a new legal system was necessitated by such inbuilt provisions of SICA which helped the Corporate Defaulters to thwart and delay the recovery process by the financial creditors.
 The IBC also stipulates for a moratorium period from the date of commencement of the Insolvency proceedings until the approval of a resolution plan under Section 31 of the Code. Unlike SICA , under the provisions of the new Code if at any time during the corporate insolvency resolution process period, if the Adjudicating Authority approves the resolution plan under Section 31(1) or passes an order for liquidation of corporate debtor under section 33, the moratorium shall cease to have effect from the date of such approval or liquidation order, as the case may be. Further the IBC has restricted the insolvency resolution process period to 180 days, beginning from the insolvency commencement date and ending on One Hundred and Eightieth day.
The Supreme Court in Innoventive Industries Ltd v. ICICI Bank Ltd (2017) had observed that the intent behind the moratorium was “to provide the debtors a breathing spell in which he is to seek to reorganize his business.” Section 14 (1) (c) of the IBC prohibits any action to foreclose, recover or enforce any security interest, created by the corporate debtor in respect of its property including any action under the SARFAESI Act during the moratorium period. The view of the Apex Court that this provision intends to give a “breathing spell” to corporate debtor raises a question as to whether the same breathing space was intended to be extended to the promoters and guarantors to the corporate debtor also. The question as to whether this moratorium envisaged under IBC shall give protection to the promoters/guarantors, whose personal properties have been mortgaged for securing the credit facilities availed by the Corporate Debtor, was not answered till the NCLAT decision in Alpha & Omega Diagnostics India Ltd v Asset Reconstruction Company of India Ltd.  
Without bothering to read between the lines to give a broader scope to the provision, the Appellate Tribunal had concurred with the view of the NCLT which had adopted the canons of literal interpretation in understanding the scope of the provision. The Tribunal pointed out that the language of the sub section is clearly prohibiting any action to recover or enforce any security interest created by the Corporate Debtor in respect of "its" property. It was held that the term “its” used in the language of Section 14 (1) (c) denotes the property owned by the Corporate Debtor, which is reflected in the balance sheet of the Corporate Debtor. The Tribunal had concluded that such properties which are not owned by the Corporate Debtor do not fall within the ambit of the Moratorium declared under the Code. The Appellate tribunal had further clarified that just by the mere fact that the assets, movable or immovable, of a third party (i.e., promoter or a guarantor) have been proceeded against before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, does not qualify to bring it within the scope of Moratorium envisaged under the Code.

From the language of this decision it becomes very clear that there is no bar for financial creditors/banks to proceed against the Guarantor/s or to initiate SARFAESI proceedings against the properties in the personal name of the promoters/guarantors which have been offered as a security for the credit facilities availed by a corporate debtor. 

Tuesday, 6 June 2017

SALE NOTICE TO BORROWER AND PUBLICATION OF SALE NOTICE UNDER SARFAESI CAN BE DONE SIMULTANEOUSLY - SUPREME COURT

 A few months back, Rule 8 (6) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules 2002 was given an entirely new interpretation by the Hon’ble High Court of Hyderabad. The High Court had held that Rule 8 (6) read with Rule 9 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 (for short ‘the said Rules’) mandates the secured creditor to put the borrower on a separate individual notice prior to deciding on the mode of sale of the secured asset before the public notice fixing the date of auction/sale was issued. It was observed by the Hon’ble Court that such notice should be in addition to the notice of 30 days duration to be given by the secured creditor conveying its intention to put the secured asset on sale, which is mandatory under the Sub Rule 6 of Rule 8. It thus mandated that the Authorised Officer has to first issue a 30 days Notice to the Borrower notifying him the intention of the secured creditor to liquidate his mortgaged assets. If the Borrower fails to repay the liability within this period, then only the Authorised Officer is permitted to issue the public notice regarding the intention to sell the secured asset under the Sub Rule 6 of Rule 8.
Justifying its stance the High Court had observed that putting the Borrower on notice, threatening him with the prospects of liquidation of assets, shall enhance the efficacy of realizing/securitizing the secured assets and that abstaining from issuing such notice shall sub-serve the object behind Section 13 (8) of the SARFAESI Act.
This Ruling was heavily blow to the Banks who were already ailing from their huge NPA burden as the view held by the High Court required them to give an additional 30 days notice period to the Borrower apart from the Statutory notice period of 30 days for the Sale of the property stipulated by Rule 8 (6). Canara Bank who was on the receiving end of the Judgement had preferred an appeal before the Supreme Court against this view held by the High Court.
While deciding the matter in Canara Bank v M Amarender Reddy (AIR 2017 SC 1441; MANU/SC/0271/2017) the Hon’ble Apex Court made a detailed analysis of the process of issuing the Sale Notice stipulated under the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. The Court held that the stipulation of the notice of intention of sale required to be given to the borrower in terms of Rule 9(1) read with Rule 8(6) of the said Rules, is to give intimation to the borrower about the proposed date of sale to be held after the statutory period of thirty days. However, there is nothing in the Rules, either express or implied, to take the view that a public notice under sub-rule 6 of Rule 8 must be issued only after the expiry of 30 days from issuance of individual notice by the authorized officer to the borrower about the intention to sell the immovable secured asset.
The Court pointed out that the High Court has committed a manifest error in assuming that the notice of intention of sale to be given to the borrower and a public notice for sale cannot be simultaneously issued. The Apex Court expressly held that there is no need to wait for the expiry of 30 days from issuance of notice of intention to sell the secured asset given to the borrower, for publication of a public notice for sale of such asset and that it is permissible to simultaneously issue notice to the borrower about the intention to sell the secured assets and also to issue a public notice for sale of such secured asset by inviting tenders from the public or by holding public auction.


Friday, 5 May 2017

Banking Regulation (Amendment) Ordinance 2017 Notified

  The Central Government has, on 04.05.2017 come out with the Banking Regulation (Amendment) Ordinance, 2017, giving more powers to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to deal with non-performing assets. According to the present Ordinance, RBI can effectively ask banks to sit down with defaulters and reach a settlement as part of the package, aimed at accelerating a resolution of the Rs9.64 trillion in bad loans choking the banking system. The NPA problem is, to a large extent, confined to 50 large loan defaulters.

Under the Ordinance.,

1) The government may authorise the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to issue directions to banks to initiate insolvency proceedings against defaulters under the bankruptcy code.

2) RBI on its own accord can issue directions to banks for resolution of stressed assets.

3) RBI may form committees with members it can choose to appoint to advise banks on resolution of stressed assets.

Friday, 17 March 2017

DRT is having the power to withdraw or cancel Recovery Certificate suo moto - Madras High Court

While deciding B Rajarajeshwari v The Presiding officer & Ors, it has been held by Madras High Court that under Section 26 of the RDDBFI Act, 1993, the Presiding Officer of DRT has been vested with the power to withdraw or cancel a Recovery Certificate after its issuance, either on application by the defendant or suo moto, to rectify any errors in the same including arithmetic or clerical errors. 
The Appellant in this Writ Petition had originally availed credit facilities from Tamil Nadu Mercantile Bank. Owing to non repayment of the dues the account was classified as NPA and the Bank had initiated recovery proceedings under SARFAESI Act. Under the SARFAESI appeals filed by the Appellant before the DRT Madurai conditional injunctions were issued wherein under the Appellant was directed to deposit Rs.16 Lakhs, which she had complied with.
The Bank had filed an Original Application before the DRT-II Chennai for recovery of the loan dues and DRT had issued a Recovery Certificate for the entire loan dues claimed by the Bank. While issuing this Final Order and the Recovery Certificate, the deposits made by the Appellant as per the orders of DRT Madurai in the SARFAESI Applications were not taken into consideration and orders were issued for the entire suit amount.
Aggrieved by this decision the Appellant had preferred an application before the DRT II Chennai for withdrawal of the Recovery Certificate on the ground that the deposits made by her have not been taken into consideration. The Tribunal rejected her application on the ground that once the Recovery Certificate has been issued it cannot be recalled. The present Writ was filed against this Order.
While deciding the matter, the Hon’ble High Court made an in depth analysis of Section 26[1] of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993. The High Court held that Section 26 was incorporated by the legislature for giving an opportunity to the defendant to approach the Presiding Officer to rectify any mistakes, including any clerical or arithmetic mistake, crept in while issuing a recovery certificate, which had escaped the notice of the Presiding Officer. The Court also examined the prospects as to  whether the powers conferred upon the Presiding Officer under the Section was limited only to the rectification of clerical or arithmetic errors or whether this was only illustrative.
While answering this question the Court pointed out that in Section 26 (2) of the Act the word "or" is used twice - "withdraw the certificate or correct any clerical or arithmetical mistake". While issuing a Recovery Certificate there could be a clerical error and there is also a possibility of an arithmetical error. Court held that if the section is read as a whole, there is no reason to read the word "or" as "and", that only on the happening of both, a recovery certificate could be corrected by the Presiding Officer. It was held that even though it has not been specifically mentioned under S. 26 (2) the circumstances under which a recovery certificate could be withdrawn, a bare reading of Section 26(2) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Bank and Financial Institutions Act, 1993, makes it clear that power is conferred on the presiding officer to withdraw a certificate or correct any clerical or arithmetical error.
Court pointed out that clauses 3 and 4 of Section 27[2] of the Act were also providing for the amendment or withdrawal of the Recovery Certificate by the Presiding officer in instances where the outstanding demand is reduced or amended in appeal, on an application made by the defendant.
From the language of both these sections and from the ratios put forth by other Courts in similar matters the High Court held that the Act is unambiguously conferring powers upon the Presiding Officer to withdraw or cancel the Recovery Certificate either Suo Moto or on application by a Party and is not limited to correct or rectify the arithmetical or clerical error.


[1] Section 26. Validity of certificate and amendment thereof:
(1) It shall not be open to the defendant to dispute before the Recovery Officer the correctness of the amount specified in the certificate, and no objection to the certificate on any other ground shall also be entertained by the Recovery Officer.
(2) Notwithstanding the issue of a certificate to a Recovery Officer, the Presiding Officer shall have power to withdraw the certificate or correct any clerical or arithmetical mistake in the certificate by sending intimation to the Recovery Officer.
(3) The Presiding Officer shall intimate to the Recovery Officer any order withdrawing or cancelling a certificate or any correction made by him under sub-section (2).
[2] 27. (1) Notwithstanding that a certificate has been issued to the Recovery Officer for the recovery of any amount, the Presiding Officer may grant time for the payment of the amount, and thereupon the Recovery Officer shall stay the proceedings until the expiry of the time so granted.
  (2)  Where a certificate for the recovery of amount has been issued, the Presiding Officer shall keep the Recovery Officer informed of any amount paid or time granted for payment, subsequent to the issue of such certificate to the Recovery Officer.
 (3) Where the order giving rise to a demand of amount for recovery of debt has been modified in appeal, and, as a consequence thereof the demand is reduced, the Presiding Officer shall stay the recovery of such part of the amount of the certificate as pertains to the said reduction for the period for which the appeal remains pending.
 (4) Where a certificate for the recovery of debt has been received by the Recovery Officer and subsequently the amount of the outstanding demands is reduced 1[or enhanced] as a result of an appeal, the Presiding Officer shall, when the order which was the subject matter of such appeal has become final and conclusive, amend the certificate or withdraw it, as the ease may be.

Sunday, 22 January 2017

Secured Creditors to have priority over all debts and Government dues- Madras High Court

In a recent Judgment[1] Hon’ble Madras High Court held that in view of the newly introduced Section 26E[2] of the SARFAESI Act and Section 31B of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993, the rights of a secured creditor to realise debts due and payable by sale of assets over which security interest is created, would have priority over all debts and Government dues including revenues, taxes, cesses and rates due to the Central Government, State Government or Local Authority. The law would govern the rights of the parties in respect of matters lis pendens.

The Revenue had claimed priority over moneys, which have been received by the petitioner Bank upon sale of the mortgaged properties under SARFAESI Act. The stand of Revenue is that a prior statutory charge is created in its favour by virtue of the provisions Section 42(1) and Section 43 of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax, 2006.

High Court held that there is, thus, no doubt that the rights of a secured creditor to realise debts due and payable by sale of assets over which security interest is created, would have priority over all debts and Government dues. This section introduced in the Central Act is with "notwithstanding" clause and has come into force from 01.09.2016.


[1] SBI v Asst. Commissioner (MANU/TN/3619/2016)
[2] "26E. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, after the registration of security interest, the debts due to any secured creditor shall be paid in priority over all other debts and all revenues, taxes, cesses and other rates payable to the Central Government or State Government or local authority.
Explanation.--For the purposes of this section, it is hereby clarified that on or after the commencement of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, in cases where insolvency or bankruptcy proceedings are pending in respect of secured assets of the borrower, priority to secured creditors in payment of debt shall be subject to the provisions of that Code."


Saturday, 21 January 2017

Where the Borrower company is not under Liquidation workmen do not have right to claim their dues by distribution of sale proceeds in proceeding under SARFAESI Act

While deciding Pegasus Assets Reconstruction Private Limited v. HaryanaConcast Limited [(2016) 4 SCC 47], Supreme Court had clarified that the fact that a Borrower company is in liquidation shall not impede the rights of a secured creditor to enforce its secured interest in the property of the liquidated company under SARFAESI Act without the intervention of the Court or tribunal. The Apex Court had held that there is no lacuna or ambiguity in the SARFAESI Act to warrant reading something more into it. Thus, there is no plausible reason to take recourse to any provisions of the Companies Act and permit interference in proceedings under SARFAESI Act either by Company Judge or liquidator. Section 13 (9) of SARFAESI Act fully protects workmen's interests by incorporating scheme of Sections 529 and 529-A of Companies Act, 1956.
In a recent instance Janta Chini Mill Mazdoor Sangh (2016(8)ADJ347, 2016 (119) ALR 120, MANU/UP/1636/2016).After examining the legal position the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court held that at the post sale stage, the rights of the persons or parties having any stake in the sale proceeds are taken care of by sub-section (9) of Section 13 and its five provisos of the SARFAESI Act.  If borrower is a company in liquidation, the sale proceeds have to be distributed in accordance with the provisions of Section 529A of the Companies Act even where the company is being wound up after coming into force of the SARFAESI Act, if the secured creditor of such company opts to stand out of the winding up proceedings, it is entitled to retain the sale proceeds of its secured assets after depositing the workmen's dues with the liquidator in accordance with the provisions of Section 529A of the Company Act.
Based on the Apex Court decisions in Bank of Maharashtra v.Pandurang Keshav Gorwardkar and others [(2013)7 SCC 754] and Pegasus Assets Reconstruction Private Limited v. Haryana Concast Limited and another [(2016) 4 SCC 47] the High Court held that for the enforcement of its security interest, a secured creditor has been not only vested with powers to do so without the intervention of the Court or tribunal but detailed procedure has also been prescribed to take care of various eventualities such as when the borrower company is under liquidation.
The Hon’ble High Court concluded that under the provisions of SARFAESI Act, 2002, in terms of Section 13(9) interest of such workmen has been protected where the Company is under liquidation and in case company is not under liquidation then workmen have no right to claim their dues by distribution of sale proceeds in proceeding under SARFAESI Act and have no right to resist the proceedings so undertaken under the provision of SARFAESI Act for their dues.

Monday, 9 January 2017

Right of Lenders to Publish Photgraphs of Wilful Defaulters in Newspapers

Reserve Bank of India guidelines in this regard stipulates that a lending institution can consider publication of the photographs of those borrowers, including proprietors/ partners /directors / guarantors of borrower firms/ companies, who have been declared as wilful defaulters following the mechanism set out in the RBI instructions stipulated in its Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters DBR.CID.BC.No.22/20.16.003/2015-16 dated July 1, 2015. However such publications of the details of the Wilful Defaulters by the Banks have been quite often dragged to the corridors of the Courts and unfortunately there have been conflicting decisions given by various High Courts in this regard.
In the past, while the Bombay[1], Madras and Madhya Pradesh[2] HCs had allowed banks to publish the names and photographs of defaulters, the Calcutta[3] and Kerala[4] HCs held such moves as unconstitutional and impermissible in law. 
However a clarified picture was brought in this regard by the ApexCourt[5], when it upheld the decision of Bombay High Court in D.J.EximIndia P Ltd v SBI, in the Appeal filed by the Petitioners. A bench headed by justice Fakkir Mohamed Ibrahim Kalifulla upheld the Bombay High Courts Order allowing the Lender to publish names and photographs of directors and guarantors of defaulter firm in newspapers on the grounds that Rule 8 framed under the SARFAESI Act specifically authorised the banks to publish the names and addresses of wilful defaulters and there is also no legal bar that prohibits them from publishing such information. The Supreme Court had accepted the view that there is no legal bar either in the said rule or under any provisions of the Act which expressly prohibits the bank from publication of photographs and therefore, the action of the bank in publishing the photographs cannot be held to be ultravires. From the banks point of view, the duty to maintain secrecy is superseded by a larger public interest as well as by the banks own interest under certain circumstances, it held.
Recently the Division Bench of Hon’ble Madras High Court elaborately discussed this matter while deciding M.R.Motor Company vFederal Bank. The High Court concurred with the views expressed by the Bombay High Court, which was upheld by Supreme Court that the banks have the right to publish the name of the defaulters by giving their names and addresses which serves the two fold purpose of notifying the public that these persons are wilful defaulters and to caution the prospective buyers who may be offered the property which is mortgaged by these defaulters with the bank. The Court held that this being the primary objective for the publication of the notice, there would be no impediment in publication of photographs of wilful defaulters and particularly those defaulters who have committed various acts of misfeasance.




[1] D.J.Exim India P Ltd v SBI [(2015)1CompLJ138(Bom)]
[2] M/S Prakash Granite Industries vs. The Punjab National Bank
[3] Ujjal Kumar Das and Another v. State Bank of India
[4] Venu. P.R Vs. SBI [[2013(3) KLT 691]]
[5] Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 37726 of 2013 with T.P.(C) No. 691 of 2014, dated 14/7/2014, reported in CDJ 2014 SC 617

No right for Defendants to demand the Cross Examination of a person whose affidavit is not filed before the DRT – Mumbai High Court


Noting that the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act, 2002) and the Debts Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1993 envisages summary procedures for an early disposal of applications before DRT, High Court of Bombay, in Sonu Textiles v Punjab National Bank [Manu/MH/2703/2016] upheld the view extended by DRT - I Mumbai that the defendants have no right to demand the examination of a particular witness or a particular person whose affidavit is not filed for the purpose of cross-examination.

Hon’ble High Court agreed with the views of DRT that the procedure provided for disposal of the application under RDDB Act is summary in nature and the Tribunals are disposing of the matters by receiving documentary evidence along with the supporting claim affidavits of the respective parties. However, in necessary circumstances and in exceptional cases on the application of the parties, the witnesses are also tendered for oral examination. Since the claim of the Bank is mostly basing on the documents, the above procedure was prescribed and provided under the Act for speedy disposal of claims relating to Bank and Public Financial Institution. Even otherwise it is the prerogative of the applicant or plaintiff to lead evidence according to his choice as he being the dominus litis of its case. The plaintiff has to either stand or fall down on the strength of his own case and evidence. The defendants have no right to demand the examination of a particular witness or a particular person whose affidavit is not filed for the purpose of cross-examination.


It was held by the High Court that the Court needs to consider the facts and circumstances in hand, keeping in mind the purpose and object of the SARFAESI Act, 2002. These provisions are with intent to expedite the procedure for early disposal of such application which is summary in nature but by keeping in mind the principles of natural justice. The provision and the power of Tribunal to call a witness and/or issue summons and/or issue appropriate order, or directions to creditors as well as borrowers and equally situated persons. However, this is always subject to the nature of application as well as purpose of such application including the conduct of the parties.

Saturday, 7 January 2017

DRAT CANNOT WAIVE THE CONDITION PRECEDENT OF MAKING DEPOSIT EVEN IF PROPERTY IS SOLD


While deciding Eskays Constructions P Ltd v Soma Papers& Industries Ltd [MANU/MH/2565/2016], Mumbai High Court held that even if the mortgaged properties have been sold by the secured creditor, DRAT cannot grant a waiver of the deposit to be made for filing appeal against the DRT order stipulated under Section 18 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002.

The High Court observed that the 2nd proviso to Section 18(1) of the Act requires the borrower who wishes to prefer an appeal against the Order of DRT, to deposit 50% of the amount of debt due from him, as claimed by the secured creditors or as determined by the DRT, whichever is less. The 3rd proviso to Section 18(1) gives a discretion to the DRAT to reduce the aforesaid amount to not less than 25%, provided the DRAT gives reasons for the same which are to be recorded in writing. The High Court held that these provisions create a jurisdictional bar on the DRAT from entertaining an appeal filed by the borrower from an order passed under Section 17, unless the borrower makes the deposit. High Court pointed out in its Judgement that the words "debt due from him" have to be interpreted consistent with the object and purpose sought to be achieved by the SARFAESI Act. Unless the debt due is secured, the borrower cannot be allowed the luxury of litigation.


High Court had reached to this decision based on an earlier decision of Supreme Court in this regard in Narayan Chandra Ghosh v. UCO Bank [(2011) 4 SCC 548] wherein the Supreme Court has clearly held that the provisions of Section 18, and more particularly the second and the third proviso thereto are mandatory in nature and the DRAT has no power to grant full waiver of deposit. High Court observed that if such a waiver is permitted the same would be defeating the very purpose for which Section 18 was enacted, which is to curb unnecessary and frivolous litigation.